Write a review Rate this item: On 26 Jan , the Hungarian weekly ‘Life and Literature’ revealed that Szabo has worked as an informant of the Communist authorities after the Hungarian uprising and made reports on classmates in University. Also, his narrative is typically choppy and the editing is poor as always. But from this clearly psychological analysis of the movie, we can easily switch to general political aspect. He slowly loses those things and people which held any meaning or joy for him. Szabo creates a portrait of a self-conflicted man destroyed by an opportunistic and self-centered dynasty and government — a man set up for false charges. But sadly, I cannot really share the praise all these awards bodies had for “Oberst Redl”.
Gay spies — Austria — Drama. Szabo’s portrait of Archduke Franz Ferdinand, the alleged mastermind of a conspiracy to ensnare Redl, is also ridiculous. Allow this favorite library to be seen by others Keep this favorite library private. Search for ” Colonel Redl ” on Amazon. Was this review helpful? His view is that acting on stage requires a lot of ability and understanding. It takes many liberties with the historical record.
Trivia Burt Lancaster had tried to mount a version in the 50’s. Szabo creates a portrait of a self-conflicted man destroyed by an opportunistic and self-centered dynasty and government — a man set up for false charges. The period detail is perfect as is the cinematography, looking radiantly splendid in the great halls and ballrooms, beautifully evocative in the snowy wastelands and suitably grim in the film’s darker moments. Alfred Redl Hans Christian Blech It’s at times witty, literate and touching, but always beautiful.
The events of Redl’s fatal day May 24thth, are an exciting crime and detective story, completely missing in Szabo’s film, where Kubinyi is sent as a messenger demanding suicide and Redl agonizes because he knows he is not guilty of treason. In response to the discovery of Redl’s treason he went after the General Staff with a vengeance, though, for practical and political reasons he could not have its Chief, General Conrad von Hoetzendorf, dismissed at the time.
For instance, Redl claims he has no interest in marrying, then the very next scene depicts his wedding; and his wife never gets sufficiently characterized. An Orion Classics release. Please create a new list with a new name; move some items to a new or existing list; or delete some items. This is the story of a life It’s at times witty, literate and touching, but always beautiful.
The specific requirements or preferences of your reviewing publisher, classroom teacher, institution or organization should be applied. Written by Dawn M. This is the second film of a trilogy. He slowly loses those things and people which held any meaning or joy for him.
That is why he avoids working in films. There are too many scenes of soldiers lining up to face lectures by their superiors and there are too many Viennese waltzes. His range is remarkable, his control of the minutest gesture superb, the subtlety of his physical screen presence majestic.
He also directed the Oscar-winning “Mephisto” 4 years earlier, another collaboration with actor Klaus Maria Brandauer.
A man’s story parallels Hitler’s rise. As a matter of fact when I move around territories which used to be part of Austria-Hungary that country was more successful country then are the countries that exist on its territory save may be Austria today.
Colonel Redl subtitles |
Set in ’30s London, the film involves stage actors and their experiences with love and revenge. Once again examining the country’s history at the time of a major upheaval the eve of WWI and with Brandauer – very ably inhabiting every facet of his complex role – giving another subtle, compelling portrayal of misjudged pride and the shameful exposure thankfully, the homosexual angle of the plot is barely stressed at the hands of the regime he had devoted his life to serving.
However, formatting rules can vary widely between sutitles and fields of interest or study. Towards the end of the movie, Redl attends a masked ball where people are gossiping about rumors of a coming war. He saw no choice, however, as his father was a poor Jewish railwayman and his mother came from Hungarian peasant stock–hardly the proper springboard for social climbing.
Both a look at the main character and the factors leading to Subtites eventual collapse, it’s a fine piece of work.
While Oberst Redl is truly a wonderful film, it strays so far from the record that its presentation of the case is historically meaningless. Moreover, I felt distracted by sets and costumes. The rest of us will find it interesting and, in the end, rather tragic.
An intimate friendship with Count Kristof Subttitles two have known each other since the academy and have a homosexual relationship–dissolves when Redl assaults his old friend for insulting the Archduke Franz Ferdinand.
But there’s something else. Yet for all the talent of Brandauer and director Szabo, we don’t get to know too much about what’s going on inside Colonel Redl’s head. A boy in Budapest lost his father inwhen he was the age of six. Colonel Redl is a made up character that is drawn from historical records and the story that ensues is based on John Osborne’s play ‘A Patriot for Me’ and we follow Redl as boy, all the way through to his high-ranking officer just before the onset of the Great War.
Colonel Redl is the second movie in the trilogy, and although it is not as well known as the Oscar-winning Mephisto, it is nevertheless as interesting and well made. But, and this is a very big but, those who see the film for the first time or watch it repeatedly, as I do should be aware that as a presentation of obeest Colonel Redl espionage case, it is preposterous.
Yet not for the sake of history whatsoever but for the sake of great thought provoking content. This film was probably underestimated redk it needs repeated viewings to appreciate all its layers and nuances. Shortly thereafter, in a spy red, worthy of a Hitchcock film, Redl was found to have been secretly spying for the Russians and had given them considerable information on Russian spies, and more damagingly, the plans for the disastrous attack on Serbia.
“Oberst Redl – Colonel Redl CD2” Subtitles
As unlikable and prejudiced as he was, the Successor, like his uncle, the Emperor, dreaded military scandals, and would hardly have created a plan to publicize a very demoralizing recl, given Redl’s high position and glorious reputation within the General Staff. One of the most spectacular Szabo’s direction is again precise but not heavy handed. But some histrionics might be expected from a man alone in a room who has been ordered to shoot himself and be quick about it.
The film is paced kind suvtitles slowly and the intrigue is never overstated, so a certain amount of patience and attention is required.